Bayer to Invest Billions in Weedkillers in Wake of Roundup Controversy
14 June 2019 - 1:41PM
Dow Jones News
By Ruth Bender
BERLIN -- Bayer AG plans to invest EUR5 billion ($5.64 billion)
on developing new ways to combat weeds over the next decade, as the
German chemicals and pharmaceuticals giant seeks to win back trust
in its business in the wake of thousands of lawsuits alleging its
Roundup herbicide causes cancer.
A big legal fight over the blockbuster weedkiller -- inherited
with its takeover of Monsanto Co. last year -- has plunged Bayer
into one of the worst crisis in its 155 year history. The company
lost the first three jury trials against plaintiffs claiming
Roundup gave them non-Hodgkin lymphoma, with the highest award
topping $2 billion. In response, its shares have almost halved over
the past year.
While Bayer is appealing all jury verdicts so far and has
vigorously defended the safety of Roundup and its active ingredient
glyphosate, its announcement Friday highlights how the legal woes
are forcing the company to change tact in the face of growing
scrutiny.
Bayer said glyphosate would continue to play an important role
in its portfolio but that it was also "committed to offering more
choice for growers" by developing alternatives.
"We listened. We learned," Bayer said on its website. The
company said it would cut its environmental impact by 30% by 2030
through new technologies and making weedkillers more precise, and
that it would also be more transparent about the safety of its
products. These measures, it said, would address questions and
concerns Bayer has faced since buying Monsanto over causing illness
and damaging the environment. Bayer also took out newspaper
advertisements to promote its message.
Bayer has faced growing criticism over its decision to buy
Monsanto. At a heated shareholder meeting in late April, some 55%
of shareholders refused to endorse management's actions in the past
year.
The legal battle could take years to resolve as Bayer has been
adamant that it would appeal decisions and wait to see the outcome
of a few more cases before considering a settlement.
Investors say the legal battle is likely to weigh on Bayer's
shares until there is more clarity over how much the litigation
will end up costing the company. At the moment, analysts' estimates
vary widely from EUR5 billion to EUR25 billion.
Roundup and other herbicides containing glyphosate have faced
growing resistance in recent years. In 2015 the International
Agency for Research on Cancer, a World Health Organization unit,
classified the chemical as likely having the potential to cause
cancer in humans. That classification triggered the wave of
lawsuits. Bayer argues hundreds of studies and regulatory decisions
around the world show Roundup and glyphosate are safe when used as
directed.
Still, in the U.S. -- where Roundup has become integral to
farming -- Costco Wholesale Corp. recently pulled Roundup
herbicides from its stores. Certain cities in California, Florida,
Minnesota and elsewhere have also forbidden glyphosate weedkillers
on municipal property while other farm-state lawmakers have
defended the herbicides.
In Europe, several countries including France and Austria are
considering phasing-out glyphosate entirely. Early this year, a
French court banned a Roundup product with the ingredient, even
though it still has a European Union seal of approval. A senior
executive of German public rail operator Deutsche Bahn AG told a
German weekly Friday that the company together with the German
environment ministry would research alternatives for combating
weeds along its 33,000 kilometers of tracks.
Bayer said Friday that with glyphosate's global success came
"widespread use, weed resistance, and in some instances unintended
misapplication."
In an effort to boost transparency, Bayer said it would invite
scientists, journalists and representatives from nonprofits to
participate in its efforts to secure re-registration of glyphosate
in the EU -- a review likely to trigger debate about safety. The
process is expected to kickoff later this year, with a vote in late
2022.
--Cristina Roca contributed to this article.
Write to Ruth Bender at Ruth.Bender@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 14, 2019 08:26 ET (12:26 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.