By Eva Dou and Julie Wernau
BEIJING -- China advised its citizens to reconsider visiting or
studying in the U.S., a sign that Beijing might be targeting the
lucrative tourism and education sectors as it tries to pressure
Washington in their trade dispute.
Chinese government ministries issued several advisories this
week about going to the U.S. On Monday, the Education Ministry
cited delays and rejections by the U.S. in issuing visas; it urged
"students and scholars to strengthen risk assessments before going
abroad to study."
And Tuesday, the Foreign Ministry noted many complaints from
Chinese citizens about interrogations by U.S. law-enforcement
agents when entering, leaving and while inside the U.S., and it
advised Chinese traveling to the U.S. to raise their safety
awareness. A spokesman for the Ministry of Culture and Tourism also
issued a safety warning, citing America's frequent "shootings,
robberies and thefts."
The U.S. Embassy declined to comment.
The Trump administration has raised its scrutiny of visas for
students from China in the past two years and voiced concerns about
academic exchanges serving as a conduit for espionage. Chinese
scholars have complained about the difficulty in obtaining visas or
their existing visas being canceled.
Still, the advisories are being issued as the U.S. and China
pile new punitive tariffs on each other's goods and exchange
recriminations for an impasse in talks to resolve the trade
conflict.
In recent weeks, Beijing has been seeking other ways to pressure
the U.S., with officials, for example, suggesting China might bar
exports to the U.S. of processed rare earths, which are used in
many high-tech goods. It has used travel advisories and safety
warnings in past diplomatic quarrels, issuing notices in the past
year against Sweden, Canada and New Zealand.
"These warnings are political in nature. They recognize the
importance of Chinese tourists, and it's one way that they can
impact on policies or on global politics," said Marie Tulloch,
senior client services manager at Emerging Communications, a
U.K.-based Chinese marketing consulting firm.
Tuesday's travel warnings fell on the 30th anniversary of the
deadly crackdown on the Tiananmen Square pro-democracy
demonstrators, and the occasion also sparked a sharp exchange
between the U.S. and China.
U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo urged China to "make a full,
public accounting of those killed or missing" in 1989. Chinese
Foreign Ministry spokesman Geng Shuang shot back: "These lunatic
ravings and babbling nonsense will only end up in the trash can of
history."
China is the largest source of both tourism dollars and
international students to the U.S., according to U.S. International
Trade Administration and the Institute of International
Education.
Ms. Tulloch said Chinese tourists and students are an economic
force, with their spending having a big impact on retailers, and
luxury brands in particular. For each Chinese student who goes to
study and live abroad, she said, they will bring three visitors to
that destination each year on average, and each visitor will spend
more than $2,000 per visit.
During the 2017-18 school year, 363,341 Chinese students moved
to the U.S. to study, a 3.6% increase year-over-year, the lowest
growth rate for Chinese students moving abroad in the past five
years of data, according to the Institute of International
Education.
Last year, Chinese tourists made about 162 million outbound
trips, according to the National Bureau of Statistics of China.
Those tourists spent $30 billion in the U.S., said a spokesperson
for the Ministry of Culture and Tourism.
The trade dispute is another factor for many Chinese, who in the
past year have pulled back spending due to a slowing economy.
Over the recent May Day holiday for Chinese, the U.S. dropped
from the fifth-most-popular destination to the ninth, due to the
trade tensions, according to China's biggest travel agent,
Ctrip.com International Ltd. According to the U.S. National Travel
and Tourism Office, which collects data from government Customs
forms, the number of arrivals by Chinese visitors fell by 5.7% in
2018 from a year earlier.
As more Chinese students flocked to the U.S. during the past
decade, their encounters with crime have been a frequent topic in
Chinese media. As relations have soured with the U.S. more
recently, state media have also focused on gun crimes and other
violence.
China's consulate in New York issued a safety warning Tuesday,
saying Massachusetts authorities notified it of the recent killing
of a Chinese citizen.
At a daily media briefing Tuesday, Mr. Geng from the Foreign
Ministry said the advisories about studying in the U.S. were
warranted following recent harassment and visa restrictions of
Chinese students and scholars. "If there is no need, China would
not do so," he said of the travel warning.
--Jeremy Page contributed to this article.
Write to Eva Dou at eva.dou@wsj.com and Julie Wernau at
Julie.Wernau@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 04, 2019 10:37 ET (14:37 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.