Greenpeace Leaks EU-U.S. Trade Pact Texts
03 May 2016 - 6:20AM
Dow Jones News
BRUSSELS—Aspects of a sweeping trade agreement being discussed
by the European Union and the U.S. are of serious concern for
consumers and the environment, Greenpeace said Monday, citing
internal negotiation documents it later leaked.
But the EU's trade chief quickly dismissed such concerns, saying
no EU trade deal would lower the level of protection the EU offers
consumers, food safety or the environment.
The world's two biggest economic blocs have been discussing the
so-called Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership, or TTIP,
since 2013. The deal would leave tariffs close to zero and remove
or streamline a host of regulations that hinder trade in goods
ranging from cars to chemicals.
Greenpeace Netherlands posted 248 pages of draft documents on
its website. The documents, Greenpeace says, comprise about half of
the draft text as of April 2016, prior to the start of the latest
round of trade negotiations between the two sides, which took place
in New York last week.
Greenpeace outlined four specific areas of concern, including
that long-standing environmental protections appear to be dropped
and that climate protection will be harder under the trade
deal.
"Trade should not be excluded from climate action. But nothing
indicating climate protection can be found in the obtained texts,"
Greenpeace said in a news release.
"It is time to shine a light on these negotiations. Hard-won
environmental progress is being bartered away behind closed doors,"
said Faiza Oulahsen, campaigner for Greenpeace Netherlands.
But EU officials quickly played down concerns stemming from the
leak, stressing that the documents outlined the positions of the
two sides and not one common agreed position.
The texts "reflect each side's negotiating position, nothing
else," Cecilia Malmstrom, the EU's trade chief wrote in a blog,
adding that "today's alarmist headlines are a storm in a
teacup."
"No EU trade agreement will ever lower our level of protection
of consumers, or food safety, or of the environment," she said.
The EU's chief TTIP negotiator, Ignacio Garcia Bercero, echoed
Ms. Malmstrom's comments, saying "quite frankly some of the points
that Greenpeace has been making on the basis of this document are
flatly wrong."
A spokesman for the U.S. Trade Representative said that while
the U.S. doesn't comment on that validity of alleged leaks, the
interpretations being given to these texts "appear to be misleading
at best and flat out wrong at worst."
"TTIP will preserve, not undermine, our strong consumer, health,
environmental standards," he added.
The leak by Greenpeace comes at a sensitive time for the
negotiations, which have entered a critical phase.
Both sides have said they would like to conclude the deal before
the end of the current U.S. administration in January 2017. But
both have also said that speed won't take precedence over substance
in securing a deal.
It also comes a week after U.S. President Barack Obama and
German Chancellor Angela Merkel tried to lift momentum for the
trans-Atlantic trade deal during Mr. Obama's visit to Hannover,
Germany. The two leaders called on negotiators to move forward with
TTIP, saying the window to strike a deal could soon close as it
faces resistance in both countries.
Asked about the leaks, German government spokesman Steffen
Seibert said Ms. Merkel's cabinet had a strong interest in a rapid
agreement on an ambitious TTIP, adding that one in four of the
country's jobs depended on international trade.
Although Germany isn't directly negotiating with the U.S. on
TTIP—the European Commission represents the entire bloc in the
talks—experts see the country as one of the main potential
beneficiaries of the deal because of its large export sector and
vast trade surplus.
Ms. Merkel was among the first European politicians to call for
closer trade relations with the U.S. and her government has been a
strong backer of the pact. But German voters—like their American
counterparts—have been a lot more skeptical.
A late February poll conducted by YouGov for the Bertelsmann
Foundation and released two weeks ago showed only 15% of Americans
and 17% of Germans supported TTIP. A third of Germans and 18% of
Americans opposed the free-trade agreement, the survey showed.
Write to Viktoria Dendrinou at viktoria.dendrinou@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
May 03, 2016 01:05 ET (05:05 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.